The Bette Davis Blogathon: Mr. Skeffington (1944)



Crystal over at In The Good Old Days Of Classic Hollywood is hosting this blogathon all about Bette Davis. I’m looking forward to reading all the other posts by those taking part. This is the first time I have ever taken part in a Blogathon, so I’m very excited to be taking part in this.

I’ve decided to write about a great favourite of mine, the 1944 romantic drama, Mr. Skeffington.


Fanny. Screenshot by me.

Based on the novel by Elizabeth von Arnim, Mr. Skeffington focuses on the beautiful, young socialite, Fanny Trellis(Bette Davis). Fanny can twist men around her little finger – they dote on her and are entranced by her- and she both knows and loves it.

From her first scene to her last, Bette makes Fanny the centre of attention as she floats around like a brightly coloured butterfly amongst all those love struck men drawn to her like bees to honey, moths to a…well, by now you should be getting the picture.

Bette was never better than when she was playing bad girls, and her performance here is another good example of this. What I find fascinating about this particular role though is that although Fanny is a selfish heartbreaker, I do find myself wondering if she is always consciously aware of the effect her actions will have?

Sometimes Fanny seems to be pretty naïve, there is a real girlish quality to her, yet at other times it seems she knows exactly what will happen after she says certain things, or goes out with a certain man and uses her apparent innocence as a cover/excuse for her behaviour.This is precisely why I love Bette so much though as an actress, she can let you see the inner workings of her characters. Bette makes her characters more complex and more human than they may have appeared on paper, or possibly appeared when played by another actress.


Claude as the long suffering husband. Screenshot by me.

Fanny marries the kindly Job Skeffington(Claude Rains, delivering one of his most heartbreaking performances)after her brother Trippy(Richard Waring)embezzles money from him. Fanny hopes that her new marriage will allow her access to money which he can pass to her brother.

When Trippy (who hates Job)learns what she has done, he leaves home in disgust and is killed in the First World War. Grief stricken by his death, Fanny withholds any affection she once had for Job from him.

Fanny devotes herself to parties and spending time with a number of other men. Job and their daughter rarely see her anymore. Throughout all of this Job’s love for Fanny has never wavered, and seeing him so hurt by her only makes us hate what she is doing. Fanny will come to learn(at great personal cost)that looks are not everything, it is the person inside who counts most. Love isn’t about the physical, it is really all about two souls connecting.

My favourite scenes are the following.

1- Job and Fanny on their honeymoon boat trip, the pair are on deck and see a passionate young couple get serenaded; Fanny is utterly convinced they too will be serenaded by this band who are rumoured to always be able to pick out newlyweds and play for them onboard. The band approach, Fanny looks expectant, satisfied even and then the band members look at one another, shake their heads and walk past leaving a perplexed Fanny in their wake; she didn’t realise(but Job did)that they are not acting like a couple in love.

Claude Rains 5

Will our newlyweds get serenaded? Image source IMDb. 

2- Job sitting by Fanny’s bed when they learn she is pregnant. He is overjoyed and wants to be with her, she is distressed at the thought pregnancy may affect her appearance and she also doesn’t want to have the baby at home. Job is dismissed and we can see the heartbreak it causes.

3-Fanny visiting Job at his company. When news of The First World War being declared comes through, Job’s office is swamped with employees asking what stocks they should buy up etc. For once Fanny is of interest to no one and it throws her somewhat. Bette is very good in this scene, going from in control and flirting, to being completely overwhelmed by something out of her control. I love how she ends up standing on a chair to get out of the way of people barging in and tries to regain Job’s attention.


Fanny having fun in the roaring twenties. Screenshot by me.

4- Fanny drinking in a club in the 1920’s with a man she is having an affair with. A drunk man keeps telling her that she is gorgeous. He invites more drunks over to gaze at her, who all in turn say she is the most beautiful woman they’ve ever seen. Fanny is utterly delighted at this attention and has a right laugh about it it all.

Bette is excellent in this film as the flirtatious, fun loving, seductive and enchanting Fanny. One moment she is all childlike innocence, vulnerability, and excitement and the next, she is despicable, cruel, vain and extremely selfish. Throughout all of this though, Bette keeps you interested in the character and even makes her sympathetic during certain scenes, she is not all bad and is more complicated than she may appear to be at first.

I always get the impression that Fanny needs attention and compliments because it makes her feel special; if she accepts her marriage with Job she will no longer feel as unique, desired as she does when she parades around with all the other men. That I can be so intrigued by Fanny is a real testament to Bette’s abilities as an actress, it is her performance rather than the writing that makes me so fascinated by Fanny. I can’t imagine another actress playing this role quite the way Bette does.


Job tells Fanny some sad news. Screenshot by me.

Without a doubt this is Bette’s film, but I’d also like to give a shout out to Claude Rains.He is superb here – endless shots of puppy dog eyes and flashes of hurt – conveying his character harbours a quiet hope that one day something might change between him and Fanny.

This film could so easily have ended up belonging to either of these brilliant actors at the cost of the other, but actually neither of them ends up overshadowing the other. Bette often said that Claude was her favourite co-star and I think they were a perfect screen fit. I really like them together in this, Deception and Now Voyager. I really wish they had made many more films together.

This is a real tearjerker and that ending gets me every time I see it.Expertly directed by Vincent Sherman. Terrific performances all round, beautiful costumes courtesy of Orry-Kelly and some gorgeous set design courtesy of Fred M. MacLean.  On top of all that, we get Bette at the height of her fame and talent, always a treat to watch. Bette, thank you so much for so many fine performances over the years, you are greatly missed.

I highly recommend this if you haven’t seen it. If you have, please share your thoughts on the film and on Bette’s performance.


21 thoughts on “The Bette Davis Blogathon: Mr. Skeffington (1944)

    1. maddylovesherclassicfilms Post author

      Hi Kathy. If you like Bette’s work I highly recommend checking this one out. I love All About Eve. I’m not a huge fan of Dark Victory, but I love Bette’s performance in that. I thought Humphrey Bogart was very miscast as the Irishman.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. kathyscottage

        I had forgotten Humphrey Bogart was in that film, but he definitely was. I think Bette Davis won an academy award for her performance in Dark Victory. Dark Victory is my second favorite of all classic films. It’s second to Casablanca! I need to watch more Bette Davis films.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. maddylovesherclassicfilms Post author

        Bette was nominated, but lost to Vivien Leigh for Gone With The Wind. Bette made so many wonderful films, so many to watch. Have fun checking out her work. I highly recommend, The Little Foxes, Mr. Skeffington, All About Eve, Deception, Now Voyager and The Bride Came C.O.D.

        Liked by 2 people

  1. charsmoviereviews

    Great post! This film is not my favourite Bette film (The Little Foxes is just so good), but it totally showcases her abilities as an actress, as you said. It’s been a little while since I saw it, but Fanny’s disillusionment, deterioration, and Job’s undying affection for her really got me emotionally invested in the film as a whole.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. rebeccadeniston

    Excellent review! I’ll have to get this one–I’ve heard of Mr. Skeffington but never seen it. And Claude and Bette did get together here! 🙂 Claude didn’t seem to play romantic leads all that much, so this looks like an unusual part for him.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Silver Screenings

    You’re right about Claude Rains breaking your heart in this film. I LOVE his performance here.

    As for Ms Davis, she is mesmerizing. I think her performance is flawless; it’s a study in acting.

    Do you know, I’ve seen this film twice, but have never seen the last 5-10 minutes? I know that sounds incredible, but it’s true. Now that I’ve read your post, though, I’m going to track it down and see how it ends once and for all!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. maddylovesherclassicfilms Post author

      Glad to see some more love for Claude’s performance in this. He was very good at playing characters you feel sorry for. I hope you finally get to see the ending sometime, it’s sad stuff. Bette’s performance certainly is a study in acting she goes through all the emotions and makes you laugh and cry.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Le

    First, welcome to the wonderful world of blogathons!
    Second, I really like your review. The boat scene was my favorite – so clever! I felt sorry for Job most of the time, but I agree that sometimes we have to feel sorry and have compassion for Fanny.
    Le from Critica Retro

    Liked by 1 person


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s